Latest User Comments

RR.com Original

The Real World Implications Of the Petraeus Affair

Published - Nov 14 2012 03:05AM EST

Josh Haven (Age 22, Young Conservative) NYU - Dramatic Writing Graduate

FILE - In this June 23, 2011 file photo, CIA Director nominee Gen. David Petraeus testifies on Capitol Hill in Washington, before the Senate...

(ASSOCIATED PRESS)

FILE - In this June 23, 2011 file photo, CIA Director nominee Gen. David Petraeus testifies on Capitol Hill in Washington, before the Senate Intelligence Committee during a hearing on his nomination. A new book says general-turned-CIA director David Petraeus almost quit over President Barack Obama’s decision to quickly draw down forces from Afghanistan. (AP Photo/Cliff Owen, File)

Other Side
"The timing of the revelation of this affair is the most suspicious aspect. It took months for the White House and Americans to hear about it. "
» Read More

Young Voters Change Politics: Our often-divided nation united on Nov. 6th to elect the next President and leaders of State. Each day, RR.com gives politically-minded young writers throughout the U.S. a platform to debate hot button issues and events that directly impact our lives. First-time voters, student journalists and new graduates from all party perspectives will address the political landscape we face in 2013.

Read Josh Haven's thoughts from a right-leaning perspective:


Last Friday, CIA director David Petraeus, ex-General, ex-commander of American forces in Iraq and Afghanistan, resigned his post as the country's chief spy, citing an extra-marital affair.

Why Is This A Big Deal?

Details are trickling out to the press in a continual stream. Here's what we know so far: the keeper of our collective intelligence was engaged in a secret affair with a woman, Paula Broadwell, who had been his biographer. This is bad; CIA directors can't let people get dirt on them, and should be careful not impress lovers with state secrets. Petraeus says the affair began after he resigned his position in the military, and ended several months ago. But this now appears to be a lie, as people point out Miss Broadwell appears to have been in possession of classified information while Petraeus was still in uniform, and as recently as the day after the Benghazi attack on this past September 11th.

And There's The Problem

Did the affair distract Petraeus from doing his job during the murderous, ill-handled attack? On September 12th, Petraeus seemed to think that a Mohammed-mocking video was to blame for the attack; this notion has since been proven incorrect. Did Petraeus not know because he was off canoodling? Did men die because of poor intelligence and poor intelligence management? Did Petraeus in fact know right away the cause of the attack? Was he pressured to back up the President's version of events, i.e., blame the video, i.e., lie, because someone knew about the affair and threatened to out him?

Oh, He'll Testify, All Right

All of this will presumably asked and explained in Congress's Benghazi investigation. But now Petraeus seems to be saying he will not testify, having resigned. But let me assure you: Petraeus will definitely testify. Maybe his testimony will be delivered under subpoena, but testify he most assuredly will. I should mention, as Armistice and Veterans Days have just passed, that Petraeus was a great general -- perhaps more responsible than any man else for the victory in Iraq, through his implementation of the troop surge. But that doesn't excuse his behavior since. Maybe he did nothing wrong, aside from betraying his wife. That is to say, let's not jump to conclusions: he may not have betrayed the rest of us. We will see.


» Click for Another View on the Petraeus Scandal


REACTIONS: